Of ‘God particles’ and (wilful) ignorance
Saw this story in the Courier Mail (our local Brisbane tabloid rag… and we don’t actually have a decent paper here at all) this morning: Atom smasher hits record energy levels in pursuit of Big Bang.
The article, annoyingly, was also titled ‘Atom smasher a bit closer to God’ for a while, until the paper saw the error of its ways. Calling the Higgs boson the ‘God particle’ is just journalistic laziness (possibly facilitated by some scientists’ hyperbole), and ends up baiting nutters for no good reason. The Higgs boson is fascinating in itself, for reasons I’ve talked about here before, but has nothing at all to do with the existence or otherwise of God, or any matters theological.
Anyway, I seem to have gone off into a rant. My point was more in relation to the comments thread. The very wonderful Jack Womack recently said: “Reading newspaper comment threads will cause your view of humanity to approximate Swift’s in a matter of seconds.”
He’s generally very right – for me, particularly when the topic is education. But I was actually quite buoyed by this particular thread. I mean, it started weak:
Mike of Brisbane Posted at 11:46 PM March 30, 2010
And the point of it all is? What will it do for the man on the street? NOTHING!
My own response was as follows:
Bravus of Brisbane Posted at 7:22 AM Today
What an incredibly short-sighted view, Mike. The same question could have been asked of Bohr and Einstein in the 1920s as they worked on quantum physics… but if they hadn’t, you wouldn’t have had your computer on which to type your comment, since quantum physics underlies the operation of computer chips. It’s impossible to directly predict what technological advances for everyone will arise from this kind of pure science, but if the history of science and technology over the centuries is any guide, there will be some, and they’ll revolutionise our lives. (As one random possibility – the Higgs boson is the particle that explains gravity. How much would space travel – and access to the almost infinite resources of the solar system – be revolutionised if we learned to manipulate gravity?)
But if you go up to that first link above and read all the comments (you may need to click to open them out), you’ll see that I had to wait my turn (I think my comments was 17th) to have a go at Mike: lots of people defended the importance of basic science.
Happy-making. 😉